Skip to main content

The German Marshall Fund of the United States

  • Who we are
    • Programs
      • Alliance for Securing Democracy
      • Asia Program
      • Balkan Trust for Democracy
      • Black Sea Trust for Regional Cooperation
      • Congressional Affairs
      • Digital Innovation & Democracy Initiative
      • Europe Program
      • Fund for Belarus Democracy
      • Future of Geopolitics
      • GMF Cities
      • Leadership Programs
      • Mediterranean Program
      • Security and Defense
    • Offices
      • Ankara
      • Belgrade
      • Berlin
      • Brussels
      • Bucharest
      • Paris
      • Warsaw
      • Washington, DC
    • About Us
    • Marshall Plan
    • Our Partners
  • Experts
  • Events
    Dec
    17
    Upcoming Event

    Age of Iron: On Conservative Nationalism

    December 17, 2019 | 11:00AM to 12:15PM EST
    | Washington, DC
    • Major Conferences & Forums
      GMF brings together hundreds of policymakers, elected officials, academics, and business leaders from around the world to discuss topics from energy to migration, economics to security, urban growth to diplomacy.
    All Events →
  • Our Work
    • Topics
      • America
      • Asia
      • Europe
      • Cities and Regions
      • Security
      • Trade and Economies
      • All Topics
    • Research
      • Publications
      • Transatlantic Takes
    • Perspectives
      • Audio
      • Video
      • Blog post
      • In The News
  • Stay Informed
Blog post

Germany's debate on Afghanistan is long overdue

October 22, 2009

Joerg Forbrig

Senior Fellow and Director for Central and Eastern Europe

BERLIN -- The new German conservative-liberal government of Chancellor Angela Merkel and her probable future Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle will without doubt continue Germany's commitments in Afghanistan. There is a broad understanding in the government about the negative consequences of a premature reduction or even withdrawal of German troops. The coalition agreement between the two government parties (set to be concluded over the weekend) is unlikely to contain any details regarding the German ISAF mandate, which is up for renewal by the Bundestag in mid-December; certainly any announcements of additional troops are very unlikely at this time. But it is a move of no little significance that the German AfPak Representative's office (a job created by the previous grand coalition government in response to the nomination of Richard Holbrooke) is being moved from the Foreign Office to the Chancellery.

The real challenge for the new government will be to obtain the approval of the new parliament in December for the prolongation of Germany's mandate. The fading support of the German public -- a majority of Germans is in favor of an end to Germany's military engagement in Afghanistan -- has already increased the unease of the German opposition parties, in particular within the SPD. The fragmented and polarized political party landscape in the new German parliament will produce a fierce debate with the new German government about the strategies, rationales and objectives of the German and Western Afghanistan engagement, a debate that -- eight years after the deployment of ISAF -- is long overdue.

With the Dutch parliament's recent announcement that it will withdraw its 1,400 troops by fall 2010, and the Canadian parliament's decision to withdraw by 2011, not to mention the Japanese government ending its logistical support for Afghanistan, the new German government is under growing pressure to make its case to the parliament and to the people. The naïve attempts by former German governments to justify the largest out-of-area military engagement in German history since 1945 with the protection of women's rights and child education in Afghanistan -- and their efforts to avoid any public discussion about hard security threats from Afghanistan -- will no longer do. Hopefully, the debate over a new mandate will broaden the basis of domestic legitimacy for Germany's involvement in Afghanistan. 4,500 German soldiers and the German people have a democratic right to it.

Note: Updated to correct Dutch troop levels.

The views expressed in GMF publications and commentary are the views of the author alone.

Explore:

Security and Defense Program
Strengthening Transatlantic Cooperation

Our Organization

  • About GMF
  • Career Opportunities
  • Our Partners
  • Press Room
  • Support Our Work
  • Core Values

Our Work

  • Leadership
  • Policy
  • Civil Society
  • Research & Analysis

Our Experts

  • Find an Expert

Follow

  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Diversity Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Credits

Stay Informed

Don’t miss out on the latest from GMF. Sign up to receive emailed newsletters, announcements, and event notifications.

Subscribe