From Strategic Partnership to Conditional Engagement
Listen to this article
Audio is generated automatically and may contain minor inaccuracies.
Summary
The relationship between the United States and Georgia has undergone a profound transformation in recent years. A longer historical perspective shows that, once a close strategic partnership built on shared geopolitical interests and support for Georgia’s democratic development and Euro-Atlantic integration, the relationship is now characterized by political distrust, limited high-level engagement, and diverging priorities. This has happened since the Georgian Dream party—founded by the billionaire Bidzina Ivanishvili, who made his fortune in Russia—came to power in 2012. Its increasingly authoritarian domestic policies and its confrontational stance toward Western partners have eroded the foundations of the relationship. At the same time, shifting US priorities in the South Caucasus and Georgia’s expanding ties with Russia, China, and Iran have further complicated bilateral ties. However, the deterioration of the relationship has not led to US disengagement.
Since the start of the second Trump administration, Washington’s approach to Georgia has become increasingly shaped by geopolitical competition with China, new security dynamics in the South Caucasus and the wider region, regional connectivity, and economic interests, with less emphasis on democratic considerations than in the past. Georgian Dream has sought to capitalize on the administration’s transactional foreign policy to secure a reset in relations without making meaningful changes to its domestic political conduct. However, its efforts have largely fallen flat thus far. While Georgia retains strategic relevance for the United States, particularly in the context of competition with China and emerging regional connectivity initiatives, the administration has shown little willingness to restore the former partnership on Georgian Dream’s terms.
The relationship’s foreseeable future is likely to fall between a full restoration of the former strategic partnership and a complete breakdown. Two scenarios are possible. A transactional reset would involve limited concessions by the Georgian government in exchange for tangible steps toward normalization from Washington, including renewed high-level political contacts and expanded cooperation, without resolving deeper political disagreements. The more likely scenario is a limited, issue-specific relationship that preserves the current pattern of selective engagement in areas such as regional security, connectivity, and economic cooperation, while leaving the broader bilateral impasse unresolved.
Face with these scenarios, the United States should pursue conditional engagement with Georgia rather than isolation or unconditional normalization. It has an interest in maintaining cooperation where strategic priorities overlap, but a relationship based solely on geopolitical and economic considerations risks undermining its longer-term interests in the country and the South Caucasus. The rule of law in Georgia is essential for a reliable economic partnership and the commercial and connectivity projects involved. The absence of political pluralism and fair electoral competition could lead to domestic instability, with implications for the security situation. The administration should therefore use Georgian Dream’s desire for improved relations to encourage meaningful political changes in the country, particularly ahead of the 2028 parliamentary elections, while maintaining targeted support for independent media, civil society, and educational exchanges. Continued bipartisan congressional engagement would help sustain US influence and demonstrate that Georgia remains relevant to Washington beyond immediate geopolitical calculations.
Click here to read the full article.
Irakli Sirbiladze is a ReThink.CEE Fellow 2023 of the German Marshall Fund of the United States (GMF).
The views expressed herein are those solely of the author(s). GMF as an institution does not take positions.